The West Is Building a Minerals Club — and China Isn't Invited

The West Is Building a Minerals Club — and China Isn't Invited - Moby

THE GIST

Washington and Brussels might disagree on many things, but securing and supplying critical minerals isn’t one of them. On that front, it’s them against China.

The European Union and the United States are nearing an agreement to coordinate on producing and securing critical minerals, part of a push to break reliance on Chinese supplies. Never mind that China still processes more than half of the critical minerals the world has.

WHAT HAPPENED

The E.U. and the U.S. are inching closer to a deal that will reduce their reliance on Chinese-sourced critical minerals. The potential deal would create incentives, including minimum prices, that could advantage non-Chinese suppliers. The two entities will cooperate on standards, investments, and joint projects, as well as coordinate responses to any supply disruptions engineered by countries like China. The U.S. already roped in Australia in a separate deal.

Bloomberg saw the “action plan” draft that’s been in the works for months. Earlier in February, when the E.U. pitched the "Strategic Partnership Roadmap," to the U.S., the countries agreed to move fast. The alliance would focus on mining, refining, and recycling projects across allied nations, with some 30 countries expressing interest in joining a wider minerals trading bloc.

Price is the only focal point. And one that would guard them against China. The deal wants to guarantee a minimum price for minerals sourced outside China, designed to make Western and allied suppliers commercially viable even when Beijing floods markets with cheaper products. Washington proposed this preferential trading zone in February, with "enforceable fair market prices for critical minerals at each stage of the production process."

WHY IT MATTERS

The deal is a culmination of years-long hardening of Western posture toward Beijing's tight grip on the materials that power modern civilization.

China controls 60% of global rare earth production and 90% of refining capacity. And it acts like it. At the peak of tit-for-tat tariff war last year, Beijing extended export controls from seven to twelve categories of rare earths, in what analysts described as the most extensive tightening of its regulatory framework to date. Obviously the Western bloc didn’t appreciate the flex.

This deal is the West waking up to a supply chain vulnerability they’ve ignored for decades. Anti-China sentiment is a bipartisan issue. And sure it has the potential of sidelining Beijing’s grip on rare earths.

There’s just one problem: The West does not yet have a functioning mine-to-magnet alternative to Chinese supply chains. Even if minimum price guarantees help, mines take years to build. And then there’s the refining process. So even if this alliance could make a sizable dent in China’s share of critical minerals, the scale at which Beijing operates will take years to grow, if not decades.

Story Continues

Some allies like Japan, Australia can pitch in, but again, not at the scale required.

WHAT’S NEXT

Even still, this deal, which will be signed over the coming weeks, represents something deeper than trade policy: it is an attempt to build a parallel economic architecture for the materials of the future. We just shouldn’t hold our breaths for it.

Downstream Analysis

Positive Impacts

Companies

MP Materials (MP) — As a US-based rare earth miner and processor, this company stands to benefit from increased demand and minimum price guarantees for non-Chinese critical minerals. Lynas Rare Earths (LYC.AX) — This major non-Chinese rare earth producer and processor will likely see increased demand and investment as Western nations seek to diversify their supply chains. Energy Fuels (UUUU) — A US-based critical minerals producer, this company is well-positioned to benefit from incentives aimed at boosting domestic and allied production. Neo Performance Materials (NEO.TO) — This Canadian-based rare earth processor will likely experience increased demand and opportunities for expansion as Western supply chains are developed. Iluka Resources (ILU.AX) — As an Australian mineral sands producer exploring rare earths, this company could see significant investment and demand for its non-Chinese critical mineral projects.

Industries

Critical Mineral Mining (non-China) — This industry will benefit from guaranteed minimum prices, increased investment, and coordinated efforts to develop new projects outside of China. Critical Mineral Refining (non-China) — New incentives and joint projects will drive growth and investment in refining capacity in allied nations, reducing reliance on Chinese processing. Critical Mineral Recycling — The agreement's focus on recycling projects across allied nations will spur investment and development in this nascent but crucial sector.

Countries / Commodities

Our analysts just identified a stock with the potential to be the next Nvidia. Tell us how you invest and we'll show you why it's our #1 pick. Tap here.

United States — The US will gain strategic security by reducing reliance on Chinese critical minerals and will see economic benefits from incentivizing domestic production. European Union — The EU will enhance its strategic autonomy in critical minerals and foster economic growth through investments in its own and allied supply chains. Australia — As a key ally with significant critical mineral reserves, Australia will likely see increased demand, investment, and opportunities for new mining and processing projects. Japan — Japan, as an allied nation, stands to benefit from enhanced critical mineral supply security and potential for increased trade and investment within the new bloc. Critical Minerals (non-Chinese origin) — These commodities will benefit from guaranteed minimum prices and increased demand as Western nations prioritize non-Chinese sources.

Neutral Impacts

Companies

Rio Tinto (RIO) — While a diversified global miner, critical minerals represent only a portion of its portfolio, leading to a mixed or minor impact compared to specialized rare earth companies. BHP Group (BHP) — Similar to Rio Tinto, BHP is a diversified mining company whose broad portfolio means critical minerals are not its sole focus, resulting in a potentially neutral or mixed overall impact.

Industries

Diversified Mining — Companies in this industry with broad portfolios may see some benefit from critical mineral initiatives, but the overall impact might be diluted compared to specialized players.

Negative Impacts

Companies

China Rare Earth Group — As a major state-owned enterprise in China's critical minerals sector, this entity will face reduced demand from Western markets and increased competition. Tesla (TSLA) — As a major consumer of critical minerals for EV batteries, Tesla could face higher input costs if non-Chinese supply is more expensive or limited in the short-to-medium term. Apple (AAPL) — This electronics giant relies heavily on critical minerals for its products and may experience increased raw material costs if non-Chinese sources prove more expensive.

Industries

Chinese Critical Mineral Mining & Refining — This industry will suffer from reduced market share, decreased demand from Western buyers, and potential downward pressure on prices due to the new alliance. Electronics Manufacturing (global) — Companies in this industry may face increased raw material costs if the transition to non-Chinese critical mineral supply results in higher prices.

Countries / Commodities

China — China will experience reduced market influence, economic pressure on its critical minerals sector, and potential geopolitical friction due to the Western bloc's actions. Critical Minerals (Chinese origin) — These commodities will likely face reduced demand from Western markets, potentially leading to lower prices or oversupply within China's domestic market.

Key Downstream Effects

Long-term Reshaping of Global Critical Mineral Supply Chains — The agreement aims to build a parallel economic architecture, leading to significant investment in non-Chinese mining, refining, and recycling capacity. This will gradually reduce China's market share and influence over decades. Confidence: High. Medium-term Increased Investment in Western Critical Mineral Projects — Minimum price guarantees and coordinated investment will spur capital expenditure in new mines and processing facilities in allied nations. This will create jobs and economic activity in these regions. Confidence: High. Short-term Geopolitical Tensions Escalation — China, facing a direct challenge to its critical mineral dominance, may respond with further export controls or other trade measures. This could create volatility in critical mineral markets and broader trade relations. Confidence: Medium. Medium-term Higher Input Costs for Manufacturers — While the goal is secure supply, non-Chinese critical minerals, especially initially, may be more expensive due to higher labor costs, environmental regulations, and the need to establish new infrastructure. This could impact profitability for companies reliant on these materials. Confidence: Medium. Long-term Enhanced Supply Security for Western Economies — Successful implementation of the agreement will reduce the risk of supply disruptions engineered by China, providing greater stability for industries vital to modern technology and defense. This will be a gradual process. Confidence: High.

Economic Indicators

↑ Critical Mineral Prices (non-Chinese origin) — Minimum price guarantees and increased demand for non-Chinese sources will push prices up.

↓ Critical Mineral Prices (Chinese origin) — Reduced demand from Western markets could put downward pressure on prices for Chinese-sourced minerals.

↑ Global Mining Investment — Significant capital will be directed towards developing new critical mineral projects outside of China.

→ Inflation (CPI) — Potential for higher input costs for manufacturers could contribute to inflationary pressures, but the effect might be localized to specific sectors initially.

↑ USD Index — Increased demand for US-aligned supply chains and potential for geopolitical tensions could strengthen the dollar as a safe haven.

One stock. Nvidia-level potential. 30M+ investors trust Moby to find it first. Get the pick. Tap here.

View Comments