The rise of digital asset treasuries inspired by Strategy

Scott Melker discusses the rising trend of digital asset treasury companies coming off of Strategy's (MSTR) successful track record.

"The Daily Wolf with Scott Melker" airs every day at 12:00 p.m. Tune in for your daily dose of all things crypto.

Make sure to also check out Yahoo Finance's new crypto hub to find the latest crypto-related news.

Video Transcript

00:00 Speaker A

MSTR was not simply another company that owned Bitcoin. It was the Bitcoin Treasury company.

00:06 Speaker A

Then Bitcoin soared, MSTR exploded, and executives everywhere learned exactly the wrong lesson.

00:13 Speaker A

The lesson should have been that corporations could hold Bitcoin as a long-term Treasury asset.

00:18 Speaker A

Instead, the lesson became, announce a Bitcoin treasury, earn a premium, sell overpriced shares, buy Bitcoin and try to repeat strategy's flywheel.

00:25 Speaker A

For a while, it sort of worked. Companies announced Treasury strategies and their stocks surged.

00:31 Speaker A

Higher share prices gave them access to capital. They used that capital to buy Bitcoin, Ethereum or almost any token with a sufficiently compelling story.

00:38 Speaker A

The market called them Digital Asset Treasury companies, Dats or Datcos.

00:42 Speaker A

But the entire system depended on a premium that had no obligation to exist.

00:47 Speaker A

Why should investors consistently pay $2 for $1 of Bitcoin sitting inside a public company?

00:54 Speaker A

And once spot Bitcoin ETFs existed, investors already had simple Bitcoin exposure.

00:59 Speaker A

Once strategy proved its model, investors already had access to the largest and most liquid version of the leveraged treasury trade.

01:05 Speaker A

Then dozens of copycats arrived, all competing for the same limited pool of capital.

01:10 Speaker A

The first company was unique. The fifth might still have been interesting.

01:14 Speaker A

The 50th company announcing that it would sell shares to buy Bitcoin was offering a smaller, less liquid, and less proven version of something the market already had.

01:21 Speaker A

Strategy had accumulated its enormous treasury before most of them began.

01:26 Speaker A

Its brand had been built over years. Its stock traded with massive liquidity. It could offer common equity, convertible debt and multiple preferred products with different risk and return profiles.

01:35 Speaker A

A smaller copycat can imitate the transaction. It could not imitate the history that made the transaction valuable.

01:40 Speaker A

This is what I meant every time I consistently said financial engineering would not work beyond strategy at scale.

01:46 Speaker A

I was never saying corporations should not own Bitcoin. I was saying that issuing shares, buying Bitcoin and expecting investors to pay a permanent premium was not a durable business model for hundreds of nearly identical companies.

View Comments